Community Mapbuilder Provenance Review

Community Mapbuilder Code Provenance Review
Last Updated: 18 June 2006.

This page is derived from information in the Mapbuilder repository at mapbuilder/docs/licenceAudit/

Introduction
This page documents the results of a Licence audit of the Community Mapbuilder project. It is done in accordance with the OSGEO Foundation guidelines at: http://wiki.osgeo.org/index.php/Code_Provenance_Review

Goal
To establish a reasonable comfort level that projects going through incubation do not have improperly contributed code, and that the code is all under the project license.

A code provenance review is desirable because it reduces the risk of the foundation, project developers or software users becoming involved in a legal action or having their use of the software disrupted by sudden removal of improperly contributed code. In particular, many enterprises will not build on open source software projects without some degree of assurance that care is being taken to avoid improper contributions.

It is not the goal to be able to prove that every source file, and every contribution to those files, was contributed properly. The onus is not on us to prove there are no problem. However we want to ensure we do not release code with provenance issues that we could have identified and corrected with a reasonable effort.

History
The current Community Mapbuilder codebase, known as mapbuilder-lib, started development in December 2003. It drew a number of design ideas from a dynamic web mapping application written by Raj Singh.

Community Mapbuilder started out under a GPL licence. In May 2005 we decided that Mapbuilder would grow into a stronger project under a LGPL licence and the licence was changed.

All developers who had contributed to the Mapbuilder-devel codebase were contacted and gave their approval to move their code from the GPL to LGPL licence. The decision was archieved in the Mapbuilder-devel email list. Mapbuilder-lib 0.4 and subsequent releases have been licenced under the LGPL. We were unable to contact Amri who had initially been part of design discussions. However, Amri had not contributed to the mapbuilder-lib codebase and hence it was not essential to gain his approval for the license change.

Email threads giving approval for converting to LGPL
Cameron Shorter, Raj Singh, Nedjo Rodgers: http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/forum.php?thread_id=7652435&forum_id=475 Tom Kralidis: http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/message.php?msg_id=12349638 Nedjo Rodgers: http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/message.php?msg_id=12254583 Mike Adair: http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/forum.php?thread_id=7653920&forum_id=475

Packaging
Mapbuilder uses Javascript and XSL which are interpreted languages. I.e. They are cannot be distributed as a binary. However, we do distribute a compressed version of Mapbuilder which removes all white space and comments (including license comments). We believe this is not an issue since we also distribute the source with license information in the comments.

Library Licenses
Library                                License  Ok? Comment mapbuilder/lib/util/overlib/*          Artistic yes     As per: http://www.bosrup.com/web/overlib/?License mapbuilder/lib/util/overlibmws/*       Artistic yes     As per mapbuilder/lib/util/overlibmws/license.html mapbuilder/lib/util/sarissa/*          LGPL     yes     As per mapbuilder/lib/util/sarissa/Sarissa.js mapbuilder/lib/util/scalebar/*          LGPL     yes     As per mapbuilder/lib/util/scalebar/license.txt mapbuilder/lib/util/wz_jsgraphics/*    LGPL     yes     As per http://www.walterzorn.com/ and mapbuilder/lib/util/wz_jsgraphics/wa_jsgraphics.js (references http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/lesser.html). There is a little confusion because the file references the GPL as well. mapbuilder/lib/widget/MapScaleBar.js   LGPL    yes     yes     External library - should be stored in util directory

License Explanation
There are no issues for libraries with LGPL licenses.

The Mapbuilder project doesn't have a problem with libraries which use the Artistic license as we beleive the intent of the license is compatable with LGPL, but the GNU site has the following to say:

(Original) Artistic License: ''We cannot say that this is a free software license because it is too vague; some passages are too clever for their own good, and their meaning is not clear. We urge you to avoid using it, except as part of the disjunctive license of Perl. The problems are matters of wording, not substance. There is a revised version of the Artistic License (dubbed Artistic License 2.0) which is a free software license, and even compatible with the GNU GPL. This license is being considered for use in Perl 6. If you are thinking of releasing a program under the Artistic License, please do investigate other GPL-compatible, Free Software licensing options listed here first. The Artistic License 2.0 is currently in a draft phase with The Perl Foundation. FSF is in active negotiations with the Perl Foundation regarding the license, and we look forward to a result which will benefit all users.''

License Assignment
Some projects ask contributers to sign a Contributor License Agreement (CLA) where a contributor assigns copywrite to a legal body. OSGeo originally considered mandating CLAs for all participating projects, however Eric Raymond made a strong case for not requiring CLAs.

In the absence of a CLA, a contributor is expected to understand the current license of the project and contribute to the project under that license.

By that logic, all Mapbuilder contributors have contributed to Mapbuilder under the terms of the LGPL license.

Code Copyright Review
All files in mapbuilder/lib/* were reviewed. With the following exception, each file either contained a reference to the LGPL or no reference at all. When there is no reference, the license of the project was assumed. Full details of the audit are stored in mapbuilder/docs/licenseAudit/licenseAudit.xls in the mapbuilder repository.

Most files contain license text similar to:

/* License: LGPL as per: http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/lesser.html $Id: Mapbuilder.js 1666 2005-09-16 13:22:07Z madair1 $

The following file had an issue with the license:

'''Library                                License  Ok? Comment''' mapbuilder/lib/util/MGRS.js            LGPL     no      Contains: "Got library from somewhere but don't know where" mapbuilder/lib/model/Proj.js	       LGPL	 yes 	 This program uses algorithms derived from GCTPC at http://edcftp.cr.usgs.gov/pub//software/gctpc/. As this code belongs to the US Government, we believe it is available to the public domain and hence is compabible with the LGPL.

Copyright Holders
The copyright holders is listed in mapbuilder/LICENSE. This currently states:

MapBuilder is a powerful, standards compliant geographic mapping client which runs in a web browser. More details at http://communitymapbuilder.org Mapbuilder source code is copyright (C) 2006 to the following people: Name                   Login Id   ====                    ======== Cameron Shorter        camerons Linda Derezinski       derezinski Matthew D. Diez        mattdiez Matthew Perry Michael Jenik          maiqui Mike Adair             madair madair1 Nedjo Rogers           nedjo Pat Cappelaere         cappelaere Radim Blazek           rabla Raj Singh              rajsingh Richard Greenwood      rgreenwood Steven M. Ottens       graphrisc steven Tom Kralidis           tomkralidis This library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2.1 of the License, or (at your option) any later version. This library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU Lesser General Public License for more details. You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public License along with this library; if not, write to the Free Software Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin St, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA 02110-1301  USA -- It is the intent of this project that all Mapbuilder developers who have been given write access to the Mapbuilder code repository and have contributed to source code in mapbuilder/lib/* may become copyright owners. Providing a patch to the mailing list does not give someone the right to become a copyright owner (primarily because it is too hard to track). Once someone becomes a copyright owner, they do not loose this status unless they personally request to be removed from the list of copyright owners listed in this file.