GitInfrastructureComparison
Comparison Table
Moved from https://git.osgeo.org/_gogs_/sac/gogs-service/wiki/Git-services-comparison
This table is aimed at helping to decide which service to install on OSGeo machines to provide hosting for OSGeo projects.
The priority column could be used to give a score of each feature, but it's not clear currently how we should determine score (a poll?)
| deployed in staging | YES | NO |
| login via LDAP | YES | YES |
| LDAP groups sync | NO | |
| private repositories | YES (no filesystem permission handling) | YES |
| external issue tracker | YES (example) | YES |
| internal issue tracker | YES | YES |
| tool to migrate from trac | NO | YES |
| external wiki | YES | |
| internal wiki | YES (edit permissions match code repo ones) | YES |
| organization management | YES (poor) | YES |
| comment issues via mail | NO | YES |
| PostgreSQL backend | YES | YES |
| Multilanguage | 15 languages | |
| Comments on diff lines | NO | YES |
| Pull requests | YES | YES |
| Webhooks | YES | YES |
| Edit GIT hooks | YES | |
| CI | external (like drone) | integrated |
| tracking of forks | YES (example) |
More about existing software packages
GitLab
"You will be running Sidekiq, Unicorn, Nginx, Ruby (plus all its gems) and then Gitlab itself."
- https://about.gitlab.com/better-than-github/
- https://github.com/WebEntity/Installation-guide-for-GitLab-on-OS-X
- https://github.com/gitlabhq/gitlabhq/blob/8-0-stable/doc/instal/installation.md#advanced-setup-tips
- https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/
GOGS
https://gogs.io/ http://jbrodriguez.io/gogs-an-alternative-to-gitlab/
Github.com
default
Kallithea
https://kallithea-scm.org/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kallithea_%28software%29
cgit
- https://git.zx2c4.com/cgit/
- https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Cgit#Configuration_of_Cgit
- http://git.kernel.org/cgit/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git
- https://git.gnome.org/browse/
- https://anonscm.debian.org/git/
- https://sources.debian.net/stats/
gitbucket - JVM
gitblit - JVM
Phabricator + Diffusion
- https://secure.phabricator.com/book/phabricator/article/installation_guide/
- https://secure.phabricator.com/book/phabricator/article/diffusion/
- https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T117071#2200208
twentyafterfour from wikimieda-labs:
our phabricator accepts ldap logins plus oauth; phabricator might still be a decent way of managing your repositories. It's essentially the same thing as gitolite but with a lot more automation around account management, key management and hooks... you have to deal with account management yourself, phabricator integrates all of that into one package (which can still be somewhat automated / integrated with other tools)
gitolite
twentyafterfour from wikimieda-labs: likely doesn't support LDAP; certainly a lot lighter weight than Phab stack, if you are comfortable with perl and don't mind doing a bit of integration work
mutante on Wikimedia-devtools says:
we currently use Gerrit for code review (gerrit.wikimedia.org) and gitblit for git.wikimedia.org. Things are being migrated to phabricator.wikimedia.org though (Diffusion). You are in the right channel you can git clone all of our server configs btw. it's a puppet repo and all public. you might also be interested in wikitech.wikimedia.org, our labs environment where you can get free virtual machines to test things
Apache Allura
- https://forge-allura.apache.org/docs/getting_started/installation.html#step-by-step-installation
- https://forge-allura.apache.org/p/allura/wiki/Feature%20Comparison/
Other Links
- https://wiki.osgeo.org/wiki/SAC
- http://jbrodriguez.io/gogs-an-alternative-to-gitlab/
- https://git.osgeo.org/_gogs_/org/sac/teams/gogs-service-writers
- https://github.com/gogits/go-gogs-client
- https://github.com/Soullivaneuh/trac2gitlab
- https://discuss.gogs.io/t/how-to-manage-collaborators/87
Other Backend Sites
Please contact the infrastructure-dev@apache.org mailing list if you have comments or suggestions regarding this service.
git.osgeo.org
https://git.osgeo.org/_gogs_/explore/repos
General Attributes
Implementation Language License Resource Usage
Common Features
Dashboard & File Browser Issue Tracking, Milestones & Commit keywords Organizations support Wiki Code Review GIST Web Hooks
Feature Comparison
login via LDAP private repositories external issue tracker internal issue tracker tool to migrate from trac external wiki internal wiki organization management comment issues via mail PostgreSQL backend Multilanguage Comments on diff lines Pull requests Webhooks CL tracking of forks